TradeDay

8.1 A+
United States Futures
VS

Lucid Trading

7.8 B+
United States Futures
Key Differences
Safety A+ vs B+ Split 95% vs 100%

Verdict: Who Wins?

TradeDay 3 wins
3 — 3
Lucid Trading 3 wins
Overall Rating 8.1 vs 7.8
TrustPilot 4.7 vs 4.6
Profit Split 100% first $10K, then 90/10 vs 95%
Safety Grade A+ vs B+
Challenge Variety 9 vs 4 options
Platform Choice 5 vs 0 platforms

Best For:

Maximum profit potential Lucid Trading
Trust & reputation Lucid Trading

Visual Comparison

TradeDay Lucid Trading

Head-to-Head Comparison

TradeDay Metric Lucid Trading
8.1/10 ★ PFM Score 7.8/10
4.6/5 (1,350) TrustPilot 4.7/5 (3,645) ★
A+ ★ Safety Grade B+
95% Profit Split 100% first $10K, then 90/10 ★
Trailing Max Drawdown Daily Drawdown EOD trailing on $25K (no DLL); DLL applies on $50K ($1,200), $100K ($1,800), $150K ($2,700)
Daily Payout Frequency Daily
$87 Starting Price $
Proprietary Technology White-Label
— Platforms NinjaTrader, Tradovate, Quantower, MotiveWave, Rithmic
Yes Direct Path to Funded No
United States Country United States
Jan 2020 Established Jan 2025
9 options Challenge Options 4 options

TradeDay vs Lucid Trading: Detailed Analysis

TradeDay and Lucid Trading are both Futures firms. TradeDay has been in business longer, established in 2020, while Lucid Trading was founded in 2025.

TradeDay offers 95% profit split, while Lucid Trading offers 100% first $10K, then 90/10. TradeDay pays out Daily, and Lucid Trading pays out Daily.

For trust and reputation, TradeDay has a 4.6/5 TrustPilot rating with 1,350 reviews, while Lucid Trading has 4.7/5 with 3,645 reviews. Safety grades: TradeDay A+, Lucid Trading B+.

This is a close matchup with TradeDay winning 3 and Lucid Trading winning 3 of the categories we compared. The right choice depends on what matters most to you as a trader.

Pros & Cons

TradeDay
Pros
Day One Payouts Up to 95% Profit Share Clear Path to Live Funding
Cons
Unable to offer a refund after purchase, monthly subscription fees apply
Lucid Trading
Pros
Real-time activations (5-30 min), no activation fees, one-time fee no monthly subscription, EOD drawdowns, 10:1 micro scaling, 90/10 profit split (100% first $10K), no payout windows, transition to LucidLive real-capital account, daily withdrawals on LucidLive, large active Discord community (58K members)
Cons
New firm (founded 2025), reset fees required after failed evals, max 5 funded accounts per household

Active Deals & Promo Codes

TradeDay
30% OFF 30% off + no activation fee on all evaluations
Lucid Trading

No active deals

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, TradeDay or Lucid Trading?

Both firms are competitive. TradeDay wins in 3 categories while Lucid Trading wins in 3. The best choice depends on what you prioritize: pricing, profit split, trust ratings, or payout speed.

Which has better reviews, TradeDay or Lucid Trading?

Lucid Trading has a higher TrustPilot rating of 4.7/5. TradeDay has 1,350 reviews while Lucid Trading has 3,645.

Which offers a higher profit split, TradeDay or Lucid Trading?

Lucid Trading offers a higher maximum profit split. TradeDay offers 95% while Lucid Trading offers 100% first $10K, then 90/10.

How fast do TradeDay and Lucid Trading pay out?

TradeDay has Daily payouts while Lucid Trading offers Daily payouts. Payout speed can be an important factor when choosing a prop firm.

Visit TradeDay Compare Challenges Visit Lucid Trading

More Comparisons

TradeDay vs MyFundedFutures Lucid Trading vs MyFundedFutures TradeDay vs Earn2Trade Lucid Trading vs Earn2Trade TradeDay vs Alpha Futures Lucid Trading vs Alpha Futures TradeDay vs BluSky Lucid Trading vs BluSky TradeDay vs Tradeify Lucid Trading vs Tradeify TradeDay vs Apex Trader Funding Lucid Trading vs Apex Trader Funding