PropShopTrader
6.0 B
Futures
TradeDay
8.2 A
Futures
Verdict: Who Wins?
PropShopTrader
1 wins
TradeDay
7 wins
Decisive Win
Best For:
TradeDay
TradeDay
TradeDay
TradeDay
Visual Comparison
Head-to-Head Comparison
| PropShopTrader | Metric | TradeDay |
|---|---|---|
| 6.0/10 | PFM Score | 8.2/10 ★ |
| 4/5 (515) | TrustPilot | 4.6/5 (1,350) ★ |
| B | Safety Grade | A ★ |
| 51.2 C | Trust Score | 75.7 B+ ★ |
| 80/20 (Real Prop) | Profit Split | 80% initially, up to 95% after $50K cumulative profit ★ |
| Forge 25K: $625; Forge 50K: $1,250. Light: None (Day Trade), trailing drawdown applies. | Daily Drawdown | - |
| Automatic at Benchmarks 2-6 (Futures Forge), Signing Bonus at Real Prop (Stocks) | Payout Frequency | Daily |
| $$125 | Starting Price | $87 ★ |
| White-Label | Technology | Proprietary |
| - | Platforms | Trading View, NinjaTrader, Tradovate |
| No | Direct Path to Funded | Yes |
| Estonia | Country | United States |
| Mar 2024 | Established | Jan 2020 |
| 14 options | Challenge Options | 9 options |
Price Comparison by Account Size
Cheapest challenge price at each account size (where both firms offer the same size)
| Account Size | PropShopTrader | TradeDay | Savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| $50K | $200 | $87 ★ | Save $113 |
PropShopTrader vs TradeDay: Detailed Analysis
PropShopTrader and TradeDay are both Futures firms. TradeDay has been in business longer, established in 2020, while PropShopTrader was founded in 2024.
In terms of pricing, TradeDay is more affordable with challenges starting at $87, which is $38 less than PropShopTrader's starting price of $125. PropShopTrader offers 14 challenge options, while TradeDay offers 9.
PropShopTrader offers 80/20 (Real Prop) profit split, while TradeDay offers 80% initially, up to 95% after $50K cumulative profit. PropShopTrader pays out Automatic at Benchmarks 2-6 (Futures Forge), Signing Bonus at Real Prop (Stocks), and TradeDay pays out Daily.
For trust and reputation, PropShopTrader has a 4/5 TrustPilot rating with 515 reviews, while TradeDay has 4.6/5 with 1,350 reviews. Safety grades: PropShopTrader B, TradeDay A.
Overall, TradeDay edges ahead winning 7 out of 8 categories we compared. However, the best choice depends on your specific needs - both firms have their strengths.
Pros & Cons
PropShopTrader
Pros
Cons
TradeDay
Active Deals & Promo Codes
PropShopTrader
No active deals
TradeDay
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, PropShopTrader or TradeDay?
TradeDay scores higher overall, winning 7 out of 8 comparison categories including Overall Rating, TrustPilot, Starting Price. However, the best choice depends on your trading goals and priorities.
Which is cheaper, PropShopTrader or TradeDay?
TradeDay has the lower starting price at $87. PropShopTrader offers 14 challenge options starting from $125, while TradeDay offers 9 options starting from $87.
Which has better reviews, PropShopTrader or TradeDay?
TradeDay has a higher TrustPilot rating of 4.6/5. PropShopTrader has 515 reviews while TradeDay has 1,350.
Which offers a higher profit split, PropShopTrader or TradeDay?
TradeDay offers a higher maximum profit split. PropShopTrader offers 80/20 (Real Prop) while TradeDay offers 80% initially, up to 95% after $50K cumulative profit.
How fast do PropShopTrader and TradeDay pay out?
PropShopTrader has Automatic at Benchmarks 2-6 (Futures Forge), Signing Bonus at Real Prop (Stocks) payouts while TradeDay offers Daily payouts. Payout speed can be an important factor when choosing a prop firm.