Onyx Futures vs TradeDay: Head-to-Head Comparison (2026)

TradeDay

8.1 A+

Futures

Key Differences

Safety B vs A+ Price $93 vs $45

Verdict: Who Wins?

Onyx Futures 0 wins

0 - 7

TradeDay 7 wins Decisive Win

Overall Rating 8.1 vs 5.4 Decisive

TrustPilot 4.6 vs 3.8 Decisive

Starting Price $45 vs $93 Decisive

Profit Split Both 90% to the trader, with ONYX keeping 10%. The same 90% share applies on the live account. Tie

Safety Grade A+ vs B Decisive

Trust Score 93.8/100 vs 47/100 Decisive

Challenge Variety 12 vs 8 options Narrow

Platform Choice 5 vs 2 platforms Clear

Best For:

Budget-conscious traders

TradeDay

Trust & reputation

TradeDay

Visual Comparison

Onyx Futures TradeDay

TradeDay

Grade A+ 4.6

Save 55% on TradeDay today

from $45

Save 55% Now Code listed by the firm 9 Sep 2026

Head-to-Head Comparison

Onyx Futures	Metric	TradeDay
5.4/10	PFM Score	8.1/10 ★
3.8/5 (25) Full Onyx Futures Trust Report	TrustPilot	4.6/5 (1,427) ★ Full TradeDay Trust Report
B	Safety Grade	A+ ★
47 D	Trust Score	93.8 A+ ★
90% to the trader, with ONYX keeping 10%. The same 90% share applies on the live account.	Profit Split	Quick Pay: 50/50 below $4K net profit, 80/20 above $4K, 90/10 in Funded Live. Fast Pass: 80/20 in Funded Sim, 90/10 in Funded Live. ★
In the evaluation the daily loss limit is 40% of your drawdown, for example $400 on the $1,000 Starter drawdown and $600 on a $1,500 drawdown. On the live account there is no forced daily loss limit: the only one is a personal limit you set yourself, enforced at the broker through Rithmic, off by default and free to change or remove at any time.	Daily Drawdown	Trailing drawdown (no separate daily loss limit). $1,000 for $25K, $2,000 for $50K, $3,000 for $100K, $4,500 for $150K accounts (Intraday: calculated intraday; EOD: calculated at end of day).
Daily. Withdrawals may be requested every day with no minimum number of days between them. Minimum withdrawal $100, no cap on the amount, and every request is reviewed by a person and approved within 24 hours.	Payout Frequency	Daily
$93	Starting Price	$45 ★
White-Label	Technology	Proprietary
Quantower, Tradara	Platforms	Trading View, NinjaTrader, Tradovate, Jigsaw, Rithmic
No	Direct Path to Funded	Yes
United States	Country	United States
-	Established	Jan 2020
8 options	Challenge Options	12 options

Price Comparison by Account Size

Cheapest challenge price at each account size (where both firms offer the same size)

Account Size	Onyx Futures	TradeDay	Savings
$25K	$93	$45 ★	Save $48
$50K	$176	$59 ★	Save $117
$100K	$228	$108 ★	Save $120

Onyx Futures vs TradeDay: Detailed Analysis

Onyx Futures and TradeDay are both Futures firms.

Pricing

In terms of pricing, TradeDay is more affordable with challenges starting at $45, which is $48 less than Onyx Futures's starting price of $93. Onyx Futures offers 8 challenge options, while TradeDay offers 12.

Account Sizes

On account sizing, Onyx Futures offers account sizes from $25 to $100 across 4 funding tiers, while TradeDay offers account sizes from $25 to $150 across 4 funding tiers. Picking the right tier matters because both the entry cost and the maximum capital you can scale to are tied to the account size you start with.

Trading Platforms

For trading platforms, Onyx Futures supports Quantower and Tradara, while TradeDay runs on Trading View, NinjaTrader, Tradovate, Jigsaw and Rithmic. If you already trade on a specific platform, this can be the deciding factor between the two.

Profit Split & Payouts

Onyx Futures offers 90% to the trader, with ONYX keeping 10%. The same 90% share applies on the live account. profit split, while TradeDay offers Quick Pay: 50/50 below $4K net profit, 80/20 above $4K, 90/10 in Funded Live. Fast Pass: 80/20 in Funded Sim, 90/10 in Funded Live.. Onyx Futures pays out Daily. Withdrawals may be requested every day with no minimum number of days between them. Minimum withdrawal $100, no cap on the amount, and every request is reviewed by a person and approved within 24 hours., and TradeDay pays out Daily.

Risk & Drawdown Rules

Risk rules are a key difference for funded traders: Onyx Futures lists its daily drawdown as "In the evaluation the daily loss limit is 40% of your drawdown, for example $400 on the $1,000 Starter drawdown and $600 on a $1,500 drawdown. On the live account there is no forced daily loss limit: the only one is a personal limit you set yourself, enforced at the broker through Rithmic, off by default and free to change or remove at any time.", while TradeDay lists "Trailing drawdown (no separate daily loss limit). $1,000 for $25K, $2,000 for $50K, $3,000 for $100K, $4,500 for $150K accounts (Intraday: calculated intraday; EOD: calculated at end of day).". Always confirm the drawdown type before buying, since a trailing rule behaves very differently from a static end-of-day one.

Trust & Safety

For trust and reputation, Onyx Futures has a 3.8/5 TrustPilot rating with 25 reviews, while TradeDay has 4.6/5 with 1,427 reviews. Safety grades: Onyx Futures B, TradeDay A+.

Who Should Choose Which

Across the use cases we scored, TradeDay is the stronger choice for budget-conscious traders and trust & reputation.

Overall, TradeDay edges ahead winning 7 out of 7 categories we compared. However, the best choice depends on your specific needs - both firms have their strengths.

Pros & Cons

Onyx Futures

Pros

One evaluation and no second test: ONYX operates a single phase, with no buffer and no funded stage between passing and a live account. Accounts are sold for a one-time fee with no subscription or monthly billing. The trader's share of net profits is 90 percent, and a withdrawal can be requested on any day with no minimum number of days between requests, no cap on the amount, a $100 minimum and a decision from a person within 24 hours, paid by ACH or bank wire. Every tier can be bought on either a Static drawdown that is a fixed floor and never moves, or an end-of-day drawdown that trails at the close and never locks. The firm's own evaluation rules stop at the evaluation: on the live account there is no consistency rule, no minimum trading days, no news restriction, and overnight, weekend and automated trading are all permitted, with only an optional personal daily loss limit the trader sets. A reset is a flat fee at every size, $89 on Static and $79 on EOD. Execution and market data run on Rithmic.

Cons

The trader is not the account holder. The live account is opened at a futures commission merchant in ONYX's own name with ONYX capital, and is traded under a limited power of attorney, so the trader has no ownership of, title to, or claim against the account or its balance; the entitlement is contractual only. No live account opens until documentation including that power of attorney is returned and accepted, and placement is also subject to the broker accepting it. The evaluation itself is stricter than the live account: a daily loss limit of 40 percent of the drawdown, a 35 percent consistency rule and a 5 day minimum. Products are sized by drawdown, from $1,000 to $3,000; the 25k to 100k figures shown beside them are the firm's own approximate industry equivalence and are not an account balance. Express to Live is limited to 6 active accounts and $6,000 of combined drawdown. All fees are non-refundable once trading credentials are issued, and identity verification plus a W-9 or W-8BEN must be on file before a first withdrawal is released. Payouts are not sent in cryptocurrency. ONYX may close the live account, reduce it, or withdraw the authority to trade it under the documentation the trader signs.

TradeDay

Pros

Day-one payouts with no buffer on Quick Pay, Fast Pass funded in 3 days, over $10M in verified payouts since 2020, no activation fee, multiple funded accounts allowed, free ebook library

Cons

Monthly subscription pricing (recurring), trailing drawdown calculated intraday or end-of-day (strict), 30% consistency rule on Quick Pay (45% on Fast Pass), Fast Pass funded position limits start small and scale gradually

Active Deals & Promo Codes

Onyx Futures

No active deals

TradeDay

55% OFF 55% off all evaluation accounts (accounts from $45/mo). Code: TDNEW. Verified live on tradeday.com homepage 2026-09-09.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, Onyx Futures or TradeDay?

TradeDay scores higher overall, winning 7 out of 7 comparison categories including Overall Rating, TrustPilot, Starting Price. However, the best choice depends on your trading goals and priorities.

Which is cheaper, Onyx Futures or TradeDay?

TradeDay has the lower starting price at $45. Onyx Futures offers 8 challenge options starting from $93, while TradeDay offers 12 options starting from $45.

Which has better reviews, Onyx Futures or TradeDay?

TradeDay has a higher TrustPilot rating of 4.6/5. Onyx Futures has 25 reviews while TradeDay has 1,427.

Which offers a higher profit split, Onyx Futures or TradeDay?

Onyx Futures offers a higher maximum profit split. Onyx Futures offers 90% to the trader, with ONYX keeping 10%. The same 90% share applies on the live account. while TradeDay offers Quick Pay: 50/50 below $4K net profit, 80/20 above $4K, 90/10 in Funded Live. Fast Pass: 80/20 in Funded Sim, 90/10 in Funded Live..

How fast do Onyx Futures and TradeDay pay out?

Onyx Futures has Daily. Withdrawals may be requested every day with no minimum number of days between them. Minimum withdrawal $100, no cap on the amount, and every request is reviewed by a person and approved within 24 hours. payouts while TradeDay offers Daily payouts. Payout speed can be an important factor when choosing a prop firm.

Are Onyx Futures and TradeDay legit?

Both firms have been independently verified by PropFirmMap. Onyx Futures holds a B safety grade and a 3.8/5 TrustPilot rating. TradeDay holds a A+ safety grade and a 4.6/5 TrustPilot rating. Safety grades are based on payout history, community trust signals, and regulatory transparency.

Which is better for beginners, Onyx Futures or TradeDay?

TradeDay may be more accessible for beginners due to its lower entry price. When starting out, consider challenge cost, drawdown rules, and profit split. Use the comparison table above to find which firm fits your experience level and risk tolerance.

Visit Onyx Futures Compare Challenges Visit TradeDay

More Comparisons

Tradeify vs Onyx Futures Tradeify vs TradeDay MyFundedFutures vs Onyx Futures MyFundedFutures vs TradeDay Topstep vs Onyx Futures TradeDay vs Topstep Funded Futures Family vs Onyx Futures TradeDay vs Funded Futures Family Top One Futures vs Onyx Futures TradeDay vs Top One Futures Apex Trader Funding vs Onyx Futures TradeDay vs Apex Trader Funding Tradeify vs MyFundedFutures MyFundedFutures vs Topstep Topstep vs Funded Futures Family Funded Futures Family vs Top One Futures

Where these two rank in the wider market

A head-to-head answers "which of these two". These lists answer "is either one actually the best choice" - every firm we track, ranked side by side.

Best Futures Both firms qualify 1-Step Challenge Both firms qualify Instant Payouts Both firms qualify Under $100 Both firms qualify Swing Trading TradeDay qualifies Highest Rated TradeDay qualifies

United States prop firms Onyx Futures is based here - 58 firms listed

Browse every best-of prop firm list

Not sold on either? Explore alternatives

See the closest-matched prop firms ranked head-to-head against each contender, with live 2026 prices and safety grades.

Onyx Futures alternatives Top firms compared to Onyx Futures

TradeDay alternatives Top firms compared to TradeDay